Can I Sue After an Oilfield Truck or Crew Truck Crash?
Usually, yes. If another company's sand hauler, water truck or pickup caused the crash, you can sue the driver and the company even while you collect comp. If you were riding in your own company's crew truck, comp usually covers you and blocks a suit against your employer and coworker, unless your employer is a nonsubscriber. Any other driver involved can still be sued.
The most dangerous part of an oilfield job often isn't on the rig. It's the drive. Long hitches, caliche lease roads, two lane highways packed with heavy trucks and crews running on no sleep make vehicle crashes one of the top killers of oilfield workers. Who you can sue depends on whose truck it was and why you were on the road.
Whose Truck Was It? That Decides a Lot
Another Company's Truck
A third party claim against the driver and the trucking company, on top of any comp benefits.
Your Company's Crew Truck
Comp covers you on the job and protects your employer and the coworker driving.
A Nonsubscriber's Truck
If your employer opted out of comp, you can sue it directly for the crash.
When Another Company's Truck Hits You
Sand haulers, water trucks, vacuum trucks, flatbeds, hotshots and other contractors' pickups crowd every road in the Permian. When one of them causes a crash, you have a full negligence claim against:
Commercial trucking companies carry larger insurance policies than ordinary drivers, which matters in a serious injury case. You can pursue this claim while collecting comp. See third party claims and comp liens.
Riding in Your Own Company's Truck
If your employer carries comp and you were on the job, comp is usually your only remedy against your employer and the coworker who was driving. That's frustrating when the driver fell asleep at the wheel after a 16 hour shift, but it's how the system works. You still get medical care and income benefits, and you can still sue any other driver or company involved in the crash.
If your employer is a nonsubscriber, the picture flips. You can sue it directly, and it can't blame you for being partly at fault. See nonsubscriber employers.
Was the drive to the rig part of the job?
Ordinary commuting usually isn't covered by comp. Oilfield travel is often different. In SeaBright Insurance v. Lopez (2015), the Texas Supreme Court held that comp covered an Odessa company's worker killed driving a company vehicle to a remote job site, because the travel was tied to and furthered the employer's business. Company vehicles, per diem, remote locations and carpooling crews can all change the answer, and the answer decides who you can sue.
Why Oilfield Crashes Happen
Fatigue. Long hitches, early call outs and drives home after a 14 day stretch.
Pressure to deliver. Loads paid by the trip reward speed over safety.
Road conditions. Caliche lease roads, dust, blind turns and narrow two lane highways.
Equipment. Overloaded trailers, worn brakes and bald tires on hard working trucks.
The oilfield hours of service exceptions
Federal rules give oilfield trucking some slack that other trucking doesn't get. Drivers of commercial vehicles used only in oilfield operations can restart their weekly hours after 24 hours off instead of the usual 34. Specially trained drivers of certain well servicing rigs, like frac pumps, wireline trucks and coil units, can log waiting time on location as off duty. Sand, water and supply haulers don't qualify for that waiting time exception. When a company stretches these rules past what they allow, it's strong evidence of negligence.
The Evidence to Lock Down Fast
Trucks record more than most people realize. Much of it is overwritten in days or weeks unless someone demands it be kept:
One more thing juries can hear about: seat belts. In Nabors Well Services v. Romero (2015), the Texas Supreme Court allowed evidence of seat belt use or nonuse when assigning fault. See what happens if you were partly at fault.
Check Your Own Policy Too
If the at fault driver had little or no insurance, your own auto policy's uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on the vehicle and the policy terms. Report the crash to your insurer and keep the claim number.
What the Federal Research Shows
Crash Death Rate
Oil and gas extraction workers' motor vehicle fatality rate compared to all private sector workers, 2003 to 2009, per NIOSH researchers.
Texas Crash Deaths
Texas oil and gas workers killed in vehicle crashes over five years of CDC tracking, nearly a quarter of the state's oilfield deaths.
Oilfield Restart
Oilfield truck drivers can restart their weekly hours after 24 hours off, compared to 34 for most truckers.
More on Oilfield Truck Crashes
Can I sue an oilfield trucking company after a crash?
Yes, if its driver or the company was negligent. A trucking company is generally responsible for its driver's negligence on the job, and it can also be liable for hiring unsafe drivers, pushing hours or poor maintenance.
Am I covered by workers' comp if I crash driving to the rig?
Sometimes. Ordinary commuting usually isn't covered. But when the employer provides the vehicle or the travel to a remote site furthers its business, Texas courts have found coverage, as in SeaBright Insurance v. Lopez (2015).
Can I sue my coworker who was driving the crew truck?
Usually not if your employer carries comp and you were both on the job. Comp covers coworkers too. You can still sue any other driver or company that caused the crash, and if your employer is a nonsubscriber, you may be able to sue it directly.
Do oilfield truck drivers have different hours of service rules?
Yes. Federal rules let drivers of trucks used only in oilfield operations restart their weekly hours after 24 hours off instead of 34. Specially trained drivers of certain well servicing vehicles can also log waiting time at the well site as off duty. Sand and water haulers don't qualify for that waiting time exception.
Ready to talk about your crash? See our West Texas truck accident lawyer page, or see all of our oilfield injury questions.
NIOSH, Motor Vehicle Fatalities Among Oil and Gas Extraction Workers · Journal of Petroleum Technology · 49 CFR 395.1 · SeaBright Insurance v. Lopez (Tex. 2015), case summary
This page is general information about Texas law, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.
Hurt on a Lease Road?
The Truck Remembers Everything.
Logs, cameras and engine data can prove what happened, but only if someone saves them first. Talk to a Board Certified trial lawyer before that evidence is gone.
